CAB Usage Trucking

12/16/2014

CAB Usage in Underwriting Truckers

Your transportation underwriter’s favorite word probably isn’t “no.”  

Finding cover for an experienced motor carrier with an above average safety history should be an easy task. However, when a motor carrier’s safety history has an SMS alert or two or if they are flagged as having the same phone number as another operation, finding coverage is increasingly difficult.  One of the biggest failures in the transportation insurance marketplace is that we don’t do enough to educate our insureds and retail agents on how insurance companies are interpreting risk information, and why certain determinations are being made – especially with respect to the usage of tools like the Central Analysis Bureau (CAB) reports and the FMCSA’s Safety Measurement System (SMS).  An introductory article on the information available can be found in this AAMGA Article, but the purpose of the following is to provide a more focused insight into a few common issues that are raising questions or concerns when found in an insured’s CAB report

 

Under what scenarios would the CAB report that a VIN is being used prior, during or after the coverage period by another entity?

  • Ideally an owner-operator leased to an insured would operate under a permanent lease; however if the owner-operator has their own authority or if the lease allows the owner-operator to work for additional parties, this may show up as ‘During.’
  • Insured may have de-leased an owner-operator or sold the equipment during the period in question.
  • A company’s DOT number may have been erroneously captured by DOT officer. This is uncommon, but possible, and can be corrected by a company challenging the inspection by utilizing the FMCSA’s DataQs system.
  • On the negative side, a company may be operating under multiple authorities. If there is a shared VIN between multiple carriers and there is also a shared address, phone number or e-mail address then the risk will be flagged as a chameleon carrier and an icon will be present on the CAB search screen indicating the risk as such.

 

If an owner-operator is hauling for the insured under the insured’s authority, is the inspection data going to be reflected on the insured’s CAB report or would it appear on the owner-operator’s CAB report as well, alongside any other firm he might haul for?

  • Inspection data is captured under the DOT number for both the company the driver is operating under at the time of the inspection as well as the driver’s individual record. This information is housed separately whereas company data is publicly available (and included in a party’s CAB report) and driver data is held in a separate database.  Driver data is currently only available to individual drivers and their potential employers through the FMCSA Pre-employment Screening Program (PSP).

 

What underwriting actions are taken when CAB indicates that an insured/applicant shares a phone/fax number, e-mail address or physical address with multiple other entities?

  • Having a shared phone number or address is not necessarily indicative of shared ownership or additional exposure, but it is something to investigate.  The most common reason for a shared phone number or address is when a permitting office (used by a company to manage certificates, process MCS150 filings, etc.) lists their phone number and address, rather than the trucking company’s, with the FMCSA.  In these instances it is not uncommon to see several dozen to hundreds of entities with the same phone number, fax number or mailing address. When this is the case, there is little additional exposure being presented and an underwriter can proceed without any further questions.
  • The second most common reason for a shared phone number or address is when small operations share a dispatch office.  The key here is ensuring that ownership is separate and that there is no cross-use of drivers or equipment. Corporationwiki is a great tool by which an underwriter can look into ownership of a corporation – as well as looking at risk information like an e-mail address, loss control contact or even names of companies.
  • Additionally there may be outdated information listed with the FMCSA (a company is required to update their MCS150 biannually) or there may be an office suite where the FMCSA does not differentiate between the suite or apartment numbers due to how the information was initially submitted to the FMCSA. 
  • If there are entities with a shared phone number or address, it is imperative that the underwriter research the shared connections.  Reviewing the dates on which authority was held in these operations (did one end shortly before another operation started?), reviewing the employment history of the drivers (on the application and/or by searching the VIN number of equipment in the CAB VITAL search), and reviewing Corporationwiki are all means by which an underwriter can try to verify the relationship.  An underwriter would likely also ask the insured for an explanation of the relationship to see how that meshes with what was discovered in the review. 

    If a shared relationship is proven, then an underwriter would review the facts and make a determination on the exposure presented by this relationship.  A son who used to work for his father but is now starting his own operation where there is no shared equipment or drivers would be considered on the merits of the driver’s history and any trends visible in the father’s CAB report. However, a risk where a son is starting his own operation at the same time that the father’s operation is going out of business is something an underwriter may decline due to the potential exposure.

 

What actions are taken if the CAB reports that the derived vehicle count is several units over what is present on the policy / Safer?

  • The “Derived” vehicle calculation is developed from the count of VINs and license plate numbers where there has been a roadside inspection during a 24-month period. Typically this number is going to be indicative of the number of units running under a company’s authority with a small swing, as the nature of trucking allows for a regular change in equipment.
  • Disparity in numbers could be presented by the following:
    • Insured could have brokerage authority
    • Insured could be utilizing owner-operators under short-term leases
    • High turnover of owner-operators
    • Change in operations (downsizing, growth)
    • Change in equipment (older equipment is being replaced now that the economy has improved)
    • Short-term rental of equipment (typically only an issue on seasonal operations)
    • Undisclosed equipment
  • Each of the above items has some additional exposure associated with it, though the degree to which this affects a risk varies wildly.  For example – a large-scale downsizing of an operation, with proof via lease terminations and vehicle bills of sale, may present a better exposure than the formerly large operation as the risk may have realized they’ve grown beyond their scope. On the other hand, rapid growth will likely present a great increase in exposure if the management/owners do not have a history with similar sized operations (vehicle maintenance, driver hiring/training, etc.) 

    The greater the disparity in the unit count, the greater the grounds for declination. Without a great deal of supporting correspondence addressing the change in operations and what measurements are in place to ensure the stability of the operation going forward, an underwriter has little grounds accepting the exposure.  However, if this additional detail is provided, the rate determination will be wholly dependent on data (resume of principals, written plan for proceeding, etc.) that’s not as reliable as other underwriting information (losses, IFTAs, driver history). Therefore, consideration is likely only given when the risk is placed by a trusted retail agent who will do their due diligence in ensuring the accuracy of the supporting documents and terms would likely be subject to a loss control audit.

Understanding the underwriting mindset and addressing any anticipated concerns at the time of submission will ultimately change how that risk is being approached and will increase an agent’s likelihood of getting a prompt response from a company or underwriter.  This can lead to a quick declination or can justify accepting the risk. The difference between a middling risk that gets held up for a week only to be declined due to an uncertainty in exposure and a written policy is in how it was initially presented to the company.




This article was authored by Liam Hutelmyer, an underwriter with AmWINS Transportation Underwriters and member of the firm’s transportation practice.

Contact Us

To learn more about how AmWINS can help you place coverage for your clients, reach out to your local AmWINS broker.  If you do not have a contact at AmWINS, please click here.

Legal Disclaimer. Views expressed here do not constitute legal advice. The information contained herein is for general guidance of matter only and not for the purpose of providing legal advice. Discussion of insurance policy language is descriptive only. Every policy has different policy language. Coverage afforded under any insurance policy issued is subject to individual policy terms and conditions. Please refer to your policy for the actual language.

(c) 2017 AmWINS Group, Inc.

Most Popular Insights

5 Strategies for Successful Small Business Renewals During COVID

07/16/20

In the current economic climate, many small businesses are struggling and some may even fail. Despite these challenges and the continued hardening market, there is opportunity for retailers to write and retain business. This article provides guidance on navigating the complex small business marketplace and helps retailers fine tune their understanding of what insurable risks will look like over the next 12 to 24 months.

What Product Recall Insurance and Risk Mitigation Plan Is Right for Your Clients?

07/16/20

​Product recalls are one of the most damaging events a business may encounter. In order to effectively respond to an incident, companies must be prepared with proper risk management strategies. As policy wording varies, it's also critical to ensure your clients have the right policy type in place to appropriately address their first- and third-party exposures.

State of the Market - Q2 2020

06/15/20

Our Q2 2020 State of the Market report provides a holistic view of highly impacted industry segments as well as overall market trends. This report is designed to help our retailers gain the knowledge they need to retain accounts, write new business, overcome challenges and capitalize on opportunities that do exist.

10 Catastrophe Claim Tips for Severe Weather Season

05/27/20

Severe weather can be unpredictable and strike at any time. Help your clients be prepared in the event their property is damaged by a hurricane, tornado, hailstorm or similar disaster with these 10 catastrophe claim tips.

On-Demand Webinar: COVID-19 Economic Impact and Future Outlook

05/15/20

As a result of the COVID-19 crisis, our industry is facing a broad array of challenges that impact insureds of every size and in every industry. In the first of a series of webinars, we hear from an economist on the financial impacts of COVID-19 and what we can expect in the future. This webinar is intended to complement your conversations with clients about how to plan for the next 12 to 24 months.

Lloyd's CEO and Property Underwriters Share COVID-19 Response and Market Update

05/11/20

This podcast features an update from John Neal, CEO of Lloyd’s, on the state of the Lloyd's market and their response to COVID-19 as well as a panel discussion with London Property underwriters on how they view the pandemic's impact both the Property sector and their syndicate's business.

Lloyd's CEO and Casualty Underwriters Share COVID-19 Response and Market Update

05/11/20

This podcast features an update from John Neal, CEO of Lloyd’s, on the state of the Lloyd's market and their response to COVID-19 as well as a panel discussion with London Casualty underwriters on how they view the pandemic's impact both the Casualty sector and their syndicate's business.

Lloyd's CEO and Professional Underwriters Share COVID-19 Response and Market Update

05/11/20

This podcast features an update from John Neal, CEO of Lloyd’s, on the state of the Lloyd's market and their response to COVID-19 as well as a panel discussion with London Professional Lines underwriters on how they view the pandemic's impact both the Professional Lines sector and their syndicate's business.

Flood 101: What to Know About Standard Flood Insurance

04/28/20

Ninety-eight percent of all United States counties were impacted by a flood event in 2018, yet many property owners remain unaware of their true risk of flood or what their existing policies cover. This article highlights key statistics about flood risk and outlines the differences between the National Flood Insurance Program and private market flood insurance.

Professional Lines Challenges and Market Response During the COVID-19 Crisis

04/28/20

The COVID-19 crisis has created a rapidly changing environment for the Professional Lines market. With the uncertainty of how claims will develop and the potential for increased exposure, retailers must be proactive. In this article, AmWINS specialists share their insights on why this is more important now than ever, including reactionary underwriting trends, D&O policy exclusions and impacts to EPLI, as well as the threat for increased cyber attacks and crime losses.

Small Business and Personal Lines During the COVID Crisis

04/22/20

Loss of revenue caused by stay-at-home orders due to the coronavirus pandemic has affected small businesses and the insurance industry serving them significantly. As retailers and carriers prioritize their focus to adapt to the “new normal” of daily transactions, underlying market dynamics remain unchanged. In this article, our experts share their insight on the current changes that we are seeing the small business and personal lines market, and how to navigate the market a this time of uncertainty.

Mind the Gap: COVID-19's Impact on the Logistics Industry

04/15/20

The disruptive impact of the COVID-19 outbreak on supply chains is already having a pronounced effect on the world of logistics and logistics insurance. Port closures, demand surges and production shifts are requiring nimble response to keep up with change. This article arms insurance brokers with the information needed to understand the changes taking place and plan for what is likely to occur in the months ahead.

Navigating the Casualty Market’s Response to COVID-19

04/15/20

The Casualty market’s response to COVID-19 is continuously evolving. With a wide array of factors already impacting this sector pre-crisis, segments of the Casualty marketplace are responding to the pandemic differently. In this article, our industry specialists share overall themes in the Casualty market and take a closer look at how various segments are being impacted.

Top COVID-19 Issues Impacting Builder’s Risk Insurance

04/15/20

The COVID-19 pandemic is causing historical disruption to the construction industry. These changes mean that risk mitigation strategies need to be implemented or revisited, policy language should be reviewed, and carriers should be apprised of all changes at the work-site. In this article, AmWINS specialists examine the major areas of concern for Builder’s Risk insureds, including government-mandated shutdowns, supply chain-driven slowdowns and policy wording that could limit coverage, and provide guidance for retailers to achieve the best results for their clients.

State of the U.S. Logistics Insurance Market

04/10/20

For decades, the logistics insurance market has been considered a sub-market of the cargo or ocean marine market. However, the continual rise of e-commerce and its effect on the global supply chain has carved out a complex and expansive industry niche. This article provides insight into the various lines of coverage, the specialized underwriting approach, and rate surges within the U.S. logistics insurance market.

Lloyd’s & the London Market’s Response to COVID-19

04/06/20

During the COVID-19 pandemic, Lloyd’s remains open for business and syndicates have successfully transitioned to working from home. However, there are notable changes in how the London market is approaching business. In this article, specialists from THB, AmWINS’ London broker, share their insight on consistent themes across the London Market as well as updates on various lines of business.

COVID-19 Claims Advice

04/02/20

There have been a lot of questions regarding COVID-19, in particular about coverage and claims handling. This claims advice is intended to offer guidance to help our retail clients through these difficult times.

Insurance Impacts of COVID-19 on the Healthcare and Senior Living Industry

03/30/20

As the healthcare industry remains on the front lines of battling the COVID-19 pandemic, staying abreast of the changing landscape and how the insurance market is adapting is critical to ensure new exposures are covered and renewals are successfully placed. In this article, our specialists share what they are seeing in the Healthcare and Senior Care markets, tips for risk control and mitigation, and how to get the best results for insureds.

Statute of Limitations Changes Cast a Shadow on Public Entities

03/19/20

​Public entities are facing a climate of change as the market continues to harden and insureds are faced with double-digit rate increases in property and liability. Contributing to this disruption are statute of limitation changes for sexual abuse victims, which have extended or removed the time limit for which a victim can file a claim. This article examines the impact of increased claim activity and discusses considerations that need to be made to better manage costs during this time of uncertainty.​

COVID-19 – Are Your Clients Covered?

03/19/20

The disruption to business and everyday life caused by the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic is resulting in an economic impact for insureds. Much of this disruption is likely not covered by insurance. We have consulted with several AmWINS insurance specialists across the Property, Casualty and Professional Lines sectors and offer a COVID-19 update.

Sign Up For Our Monthly Newsletter

Sign Up