What Product Recall Insurance and Risk Mitigation Plan Is Right for Your Clients?

Product recalls are one of the most damaging events a business may encounter, and the consequences can be overwhelming. Each year, the number of product contamination and recall incidents continue to rise, especially in the food and beverage, consumer product and automotive sectors. According to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the number of recalled units increased by 319% in the food and beverage space in 2019, consumer products had 261 consumer product recalls between Q4 2018 and Q3 2019, and the automotive industry has had an average of 180 to 220 recalls per quarter since 2014.

Several factors have contributed to the increase of recalls in recent years.

  • Improved testing and traceability technology, including Whole Genome Sequencing, enable the public to more accurately and quickly determine the cause and source of foodborne outbreaks.
  • Advocacy organizations are more vocal than ever. In their mission to protect consumers, they can easily turn a small incident into a wide-spread campaign.
  • The regulatory environment is constantly evolving, which complicates an already complex crisis.

Additionally, the ongoing pandemic has put consumers on high alert. Scientific research has found that foodborne transmission of COVID-19 is not likely. However, it may be possible for RNA from dead viruses including COVID-19 to be found in food. This RNA is not harmful or a mode of transmission. The presence of RNA would not likely trigger a Product Contamination policy, but carriers are concerned that insureds may file claims because of detection of RNA. 

Companies are often adept at managing and transferring various business risks, but lag when it comes to addressing large-scale product recalls. In order to successfully navigate recalls, businesses must be prepared to effectively manage an event through proper risk management strategies and insurance coverage.


Risk Management and Mitigation: A Business’ Safety Net

The first step in managing the risk of product recalls is pre-incident planning. No amount of insurance can replace lost consumer confidence due to poor planning and/or execution of a recall crisis strategy. If the public perceives that your products are unsafe or that you are more concerned with your bottom line than their safety, your business will suffer. Every company should have the following in place.

  1. Communication plan to disseminate appropriate information. Once an incident (or suspected incident) becomes known to the media, a company can expect difficult questions from a range of interested parties. First and foremost, their customers will need to have a clear understanding of the potential danger and measures the company is taking to minimize or eliminate the danger. Likewise, government agencies, suppliers, distributors and other external parties will have questions on how this affects them. Internal company employees including marketing, public relations, quality control and general counsel will also seek information and direction.
  2. Retrieval and notification plan to recover contaminated product. Every company should have a well-documented and practiced product recall retrieval plan to quickly and efficiently identify, locate and recover any suspected contaminated product. The plan needs to include customer, vendor, distributor and retailer notification procedures, as well as appropriate notification messages to be sent through the media. The phrase “bad news travels fast” has never been truer than in today’s viral news and social media culture. Managing the message and providing accurate and timely information will greatly enhance the retrieval process.
  3. Crisis management plan to coordinate roles and responsibilities during the recall. A crisis management plan goes beyond the recall retrieval plan and coordinates all activities associated with the event. This plan defines the crisis management team and their respective roles in responding to certain aspects of the crisis. Team members may include the chief executive officer, general counsel, risk manager and representatives from security, marketing, public relations, quality control, human resources, distribution and manufacturing. In many instances, the crisis team is supplemented by outside members such as agency partners and consultants. All members need to be reachable and ready to act at a moment’s notice.


Are Recalls Covered Under General and Products Liability Policies?

Mistakenly, many companies believe they are protected for product recalls/contamination events under their general or products liability policy. While these policies cover liability from bodily injury and property damage, they do not provide coverage for product recalls. In fact, standard ISO forms specifically exclude “damages claimed for any loss, cost or expense incurred by you or others for the loss of use, withdrawal, recall, inspection, repair, replacement, adjustment, removal or disposal of your product, your work or impaired property.”

Although some liability carriers may provide an extension for product withdrawals, these are almost always subject to a minimal sublimit and are limited to first-party recall expenses only. These extensions do not cover both first-party loss of income, profits or extra expense and those incurred by the insured’s customers. Standalone product contamination and product recall policies are not only broader in scope, but they provide substantially greater coverage than a withdrawal endorsement on a liability policy.


Product Recall vs. Product Contamination Policies – Which is Right for Your Client?

Product contamination insurance, also referred to as accidental contamination and malicious tampering insurance, is generally aimed at food and beverage manufacturers, distributors and retailers. These policies tend to offer broad first-party coverage including loss of income. Typically, these policies are triggered either by an actual or suspected accidental contamination or malicious tampering. Accidental contamination generally requires the belief that bodily injury or property damage would occur if the product was used.

Product recall insurance policies differ from product contamination insurance policies in two primary ways.

  1. When the policy is triggered. While both types of policies require the potential for bodily injury or property damage to be evident, product recall policies are triggered by the withdrawal of the product from the market and contamination policies by the contamination of the product itself. Therefore, products still in an insured’s possession (warehoused for instance) may not be covered under a product recall policy, as the product has not been “recalled,” but would be covered under a contamination policy. It’s worth noting that some product recall policies have begun to be amended to include product still in the insured’s possession.
  2. Availability of impaired property trigger. The impaired property trigger is available in conjunction with product recall policies but is not offered with product contamination policies at this time. The impaired property trigger expands normal coverage to include incidents in which tangible property beyond the insured’s product(s) becomes useless or less useful because it incorporates the insured’s deficient, defective or inadequate product. For example, the product broadens the coverage trigger to include protection for an auto part component failing to perform its function. A similar trigger designed especially for auto parts called product guarantee is available in the London market.

It is very important to fully understand the exposures faced by an insured when deciding whether a recall or contamination policy provides the proper protection.


Emerging Coverage: Government Advisory Coverage

After four major E. coli outbreaks over the past two years involving romaine lettuce, the leafy greens industry is reeling. Each of these outbreaks resulted in the CDC and FDA issuing advisories, instructing the public not to distribute or consume romaine lettuce. The reason being that the source of the outbreak was unable to be identified and deficiencies in traceability prevented the public from differentiating between safe and contaminated lettuce. 

These advisories created a unique challenge for product contamination policies, because such polices are only triggered by an actual contamination of the insured’s product.  Romaine lettuce producers across the country were forced to withdraw and dispose of their romaine, even though there was no evidence that their product was contaminated.  As a result, they were not indemnified by their product contamination policies. 

In an effort to address this issue, the product recall insurance community has been working to develop a policy trigger for government advisories. The policy would be triggered by the existence of a government advisory, instructing the public not to consume or distribute any product that is similar to the insured’s product(s). As of June 2020, only one market is willing to offer this coverage on a limited basis, and a handful of additional markets are working towards an offering.



The product recall and contamination insurance marketplace is very specialized and should be approached in a well-thought-out manner. Given the limited number of insurers willing to participate in this market, it is important that all options are thoroughly reviewed and properly approached. Ensuring that proper risk management and mitigation procedures are in place and that both first- and third-party exposures are properly addressed is the key to building a well-rounded policy that will ensure optimal indemnification should a loss occur. 


About the Authors


The article was authored by Matt Carpenter and Robert Balogh, product recall insurance specialists with AmWINS Brokerage in Chicago, IL.

The product recall specialists at AmWINS are dedicated to helping our retail partners provide insurance and risk management solutions for manufacturers and distributors of nearly any conceivable product. As a leader in the product recall wholesale brokerage space, we have helped thousands of insureds, including numerous Fortune 500 companies, understand and manage their product recall and product contamination risks. Learn more at amwins.com/product-recall.


Contact Us

To learn more about how AmWINS can help you place coverage for your clients, reach out to your local AmWINS broker.  If you do not have a contact at AmWINS, please click here.

Legal Disclaimer. Views expressed here do not constitute legal advice. The information contained herein is for general guidance of matter only and not for the purpose of providing legal advice. Discussion of insurance policy language is descriptive only. Every policy has different policy language. Coverage afforded under any insurance policy issued is subject to individual policy terms and conditions. Please refer to your policy for the actual language.

(c) 2017 AmWINS Group, Inc.

Most Popular Insights

Unpacking Warehouse Legal Liability


Warehouse legal liability is a complicated line with many gray areas and multiple interpretations of its coverages. This article discusses coverage triggers, legal vs. contractual liability and the importance of warehouse receipts.

5 Strategies for Successful Small Business Renewals During COVID


In the current economic climate, many small businesses are struggling and some may even fail. Despite these challenges and the continued hardening market, there is opportunity for retailers to write and retain business. This article provides guidance on navigating the complex small business marketplace and helps retailers fine tune their understanding of what insurable risks will look like over the next 12 to 24 months.

What Product Recall Insurance and Risk Mitigation Plan Is Right for Your Clients?


​Product recalls are one of the most damaging events a business may encounter. In order to effectively respond to an incident, companies must be prepared with proper risk management strategies. As policy wording varies, it's also critical to ensure your clients have the right policy type in place to appropriately address their first- and third-party exposures.

Is Your Insured’s Website Compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act?


Court rulings, have extended the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to apply to websites that are "heavily integrated" with and serve as a "gateway" to a physical stores/services. As a result, companies are now finding themselves targets for ADA claims based on the inaccessibility of their websites and media by those who are disabled.

State of the Market - Q2 2020


Our Q2 2020 State of the Market report provides a holistic view of highly impacted industry segments as well as overall market trends. This report is designed to help our retailers gain the knowledge they need to retain accounts, write new business, overcome challenges and capitalize on opportunities that do exist.

10 Catastrophe Claim Tips for Severe Weather Season


Severe weather can be unpredictable and strike at any time. Help your clients be prepared in the event their property is damaged by a hurricane, tornado, hailstorm or similar disaster with these 10 catastrophe claim tips.

On-Demand Webinar: COVID-19 Economic Impact and Future Outlook


As a result of the COVID-19 crisis, our industry is facing a broad array of challenges that impact insureds of every size and in every industry. In the first of a series of webinars, we hear from an economist on the financial impacts of COVID-19 and what we can expect in the future. This webinar is intended to complement your conversations with clients about how to plan for the next 12 to 24 months.

Lloyd's CEO and Property Underwriters Share COVID-19 Response and Market Update


This podcast features an update from John Neal, CEO of Lloyd’s, on the state of the Lloyd's market and their response to COVID-19 as well as a panel discussion with London Property underwriters on how they view the pandemic's impact both the Property sector and their syndicate's business.

Lloyd's CEO and Casualty Underwriters Share COVID-19 Response and Market Update


This podcast features an update from John Neal, CEO of Lloyd’s, on the state of the Lloyd's market and their response to COVID-19 as well as a panel discussion with London Casualty underwriters on how they view the pandemic's impact both the Casualty sector and their syndicate's business.

Lloyd's CEO and Professional Underwriters Share COVID-19 Response and Market Update


This podcast features an update from John Neal, CEO of Lloyd’s, on the state of the Lloyd's market and their response to COVID-19 as well as a panel discussion with London Professional Lines underwriters on how they view the pandemic's impact both the Professional Lines sector and their syndicate's business.

Flood 101: What to Know About Standard Flood Insurance


Ninety-eight percent of all United States counties were impacted by a flood event in 2018, yet many property owners remain unaware of their true risk of flood or what their existing policies cover. This article highlights key statistics about flood risk and outlines the differences between the National Flood Insurance Program and private market flood insurance.

Professional Lines Challenges and Market Response During the COVID-19 Crisis


The COVID-19 crisis has created a rapidly changing environment for the Professional Lines market. With the uncertainty of how claims will develop and the potential for increased exposure, retailers must be proactive. In this article, AmWINS specialists share their insights on why this is more important now than ever, including reactionary underwriting trends, D&O policy exclusions and impacts to EPLI, as well as the threat for increased cyber attacks and crime losses.

Small Business and Personal Lines During the COVID Crisis


Loss of revenue caused by stay-at-home orders due to the coronavirus pandemic has affected small businesses and the insurance industry serving them significantly. As retailers and carriers prioritize their focus to adapt to the “new normal” of daily transactions, underlying market dynamics remain unchanged. In this article, our experts share their insight on the current changes that we are seeing the small business and personal lines market, and how to navigate the market a this time of uncertainty.

Mind the Gap: COVID-19's Impact on the Logistics Industry


The disruptive impact of the COVID-19 outbreak on supply chains is already having a pronounced effect on the world of logistics and logistics insurance. Port closures, demand surges and production shifts are requiring nimble response to keep up with change. This article arms insurance brokers with the information needed to understand the changes taking place and plan for what is likely to occur in the months ahead.

Navigating the Casualty Market’s Response to COVID-19


The Casualty market’s response to COVID-19 is continuously evolving. With a wide array of factors already impacting this sector pre-crisis, segments of the Casualty marketplace are responding to the pandemic differently. In this article, our industry specialists share overall themes in the Casualty market and take a closer look at how various segments are being impacted.

Top COVID-19 Issues Impacting Builder’s Risk Insurance


The COVID-19 pandemic is causing historical disruption to the construction industry. These changes mean that risk mitigation strategies need to be implemented or revisited, policy language should be reviewed, and carriers should be apprised of all changes at the work-site. In this article, AmWINS specialists examine the major areas of concern for Builder’s Risk insureds, including government-mandated shutdowns, supply chain-driven slowdowns and policy wording that could limit coverage, and provide guidance for retailers to achieve the best results for their clients.

State of the U.S. Logistics Insurance Market


For decades, the logistics insurance market has been considered a sub-market of the cargo or ocean marine market. However, the continual rise of e-commerce and its effect on the global supply chain has carved out a complex and expansive industry niche. This article provides insight into the various lines of coverage, the specialized underwriting approach, and rate surges within the U.S. logistics insurance market.

Lloyd’s & the London Market’s Response to COVID-19


During the COVID-19 pandemic, Lloyd’s remains open for business and syndicates have successfully transitioned to working from home. However, there are notable changes in how the London market is approaching business. In this article, specialists from THB, AmWINS’ London broker, share their insight on consistent themes across the London Market as well as updates on various lines of business.

COVID-19 Claims Advice


There have been a lot of questions regarding COVID-19, in particular about coverage and claims handling. This claims advice is intended to offer guidance to help our retail clients through these difficult times.

Insurance Impacts of COVID-19 on the Healthcare and Senior Living Industry


As the healthcare industry remains on the front lines of battling the COVID-19 pandemic, staying abreast of the changing landscape and how the insurance market is adapting is critical to ensure new exposures are covered and renewals are successfully placed. In this article, our specialists share what they are seeing in the Healthcare and Senior Care markets, tips for risk control and mitigation, and how to get the best results for insureds.

Sign Up For Our Monthly Newsletter

Sign Up